Colour illustration from volume 8.

Fanfiction is one of those things which are forevermore shrouded in controversy, at least among fandoms. The arguments for and against are endless, and I don't really want to have to deal with them right now, so we'll just all agree to disagree, or perhaps agree to agree, as the case may be. I'm very agreeable at the moment, largely because agreeing with stuff might make them go away and stop bothering my and my headache.

However, I've noticed that there's at least a significant contingent of people for whom fanfiction is not the Spawn of Slaanesh, and yet it holds no particular attraction of any sort. One of the most common refrains heard is: "I haven't read any fanfics I liked."

Cue the inevitable deluge of fanfic recommendations, of which this post is one. So it goes.

Trying to recommend fanfics to another person is extremely difficult, if only because due to its nature as entertainment, it is subject to personal opinions and tastes, which are, well, personal. Just because I like the idea of, say, crossing over Card Captor Sakura and Star Wars doesn't mean that anyone else would, and it is in these tiny details which readers are converted or cast away.

Black and white illustration from volume 8.

The most obvious question when asked for a fanfic rec is: which fandom? Fanfiction tends to assume that the reader already knows the original story; there is little point in recapping the canon plot in an As You Know chunk of text, since the point of fanfic is to address that which the canon left unattended, whether it is an alternate interpretation, or some aspect of the setting which the writers unaccountably very accountably left as an exercise for the viewers. This becomes rather more complex when it comes to crossovers, which have to account for two or more series at once, and present them in a way that does not leave anyone who has not seen all the series in question hopelessly lost.

This, along with trying to fix what the original creators broke, I am of the firm belief that anyone who says writing fanfiction is easier than writing original stories is very much mistaken.

Once we have fandoms settled, now we shall come to subject matter. Angst, comedy, spam, dark, WAFF, crossover, fusion, drabble, AU, OC… the terms are endless, and endlessly debated. What, exactly, does "AU" imply? Is it a completely transplanted setting with the main characters intact? Or do we keep the setting, but change the characters? One person may have a Definitive Answer, and another might have another Answer just as Definitive, but mutually exclusive with the first. The perils of fandom definitions are many.

And that's not even going into what might be the major topic of possibly the majority of fanfics. Het, yaoi, yuri, gen? Which characters? How explicit are we talking about? Just chatting, or is there some serious boinking to be had?

After that, I cannot quite blame the fans timidly dipping their toes into the vast ocean of fanfiction in being intimidated. This is worse than calculus; I know this because I find fanfic conventions puzzling, but calculus is easy.

Now that I've inadvertantly managed to scare away most of my readership, I should probably get on with the fanfic recs.

I should note that this is, by no means whatsoever, a complete list of fanfics which I like. Rather, this is a very short list of fanfics which I can think of at the moment, and which I can find a source. My list of fanfic bookmarks were lost in one of the drastic computer crashes which plague me like unreliable clockwork, and so I operate mostly on faulty memory. I'm fairly sure that right after I post this, I'll remember some more.

Most of these are also not pairing-centric. I'm not really interested in pairings as such; I have nothing against the concept, but it's just a factor which is placed into the story, like an extra ingredient in a dish. It could be significant, but I'm more concerned with the whole thing. If that makes any sense.

Let's see if I still remember my HTML. I think UL and LI are still XHTML-compliant rather than deprecated? I forget, especially since I'm not that familiar with CSS. Ah well.

In no particular order:

  • Paradise Lost, by Andy Kent. A Ranma 1/2/Neon Genesis Evangelion crossover, with Ryouga Hibiki taking the place of Shinji Ikari. (Yes, really.) The rest of the characters, introduced as Ryouga commutes (with the help of Rei Ayanami wielding a GPS unit) between NERV HQ and Nerima, are as in the canons, mostly. The story takes place at some indeterminate time after the loose continuity of the Ranma-verse, while also retelling the plot of NGE (possibly because there isn't really an "after the canon" for NGE), albeit with mysterious additions involving the Jusenkyo springs. Unfinished, and likely completely abandoned, considering the last update was several years ago.
  • Slayers Trilogy, by Twoflower. Slayers and sequels, ignoring some of the inconvenient plot points of TRY (like eventual fate of the Sword of Light). Keeping fairly close to the feel of the series, with Wacky Hijinks and Slapstick Comedy overlaying a surprisingly serious and epic plot, the story goes from Lina breaking a magical artefact (by accident, rather than by intent or by collateral damage), and builds up all the way to deciding the fate of the universe. Unusually for a lengthy work of fanfic, it's completed. Don't hesitate to check out the rest of Twoflower's works, in fiction (fan and original) and game design. The man is talented.
  • Rod M has plenty of good stories, most of which are sadly unfinished. I was first introduced via The More Things Change, a Ranma 1/2 story with Ryouga as the main character, gradually accumulating mortal enemies and fiancees… like Ranma had before him, the realization of which Ryouga has some objection towards. And then there's his growing friendship with Ukyou Kuonji… TMTC is technically completed, but the sequel, The Pursuit of Happiness, is not. It does involve the King of Nerima tournament arc, which reaffirms some series truths.
  • Also from Rod M, we have Dire Fates, which takes the Vertigo comics Hellblazer John Constantine, and combines it with Ah My Goddess. And it actually works, to the point where I credit this fanfic as introducing me to AMG, even though at the time I had not known anything about either series involved. (I have yet to pick up Hellblazer, mostly because it looks to be too, well, dark.) There's a sequel in Mortal Fates, which is mostly Belldandy-introspection on the events in DF. And for extra points, let's have Sailor Hellblazer, which is indeed Hellblazer crossed over with Sailor Moon. And it is awesome.

Yes, I know that there are no Card Captor Sakura or Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya fanfics in that list. Like I said, I lost my bookmarks (and so have no CCS stories to share), and I haven't seriously had a look at the genfic (ie non-pairing) MoHS fandom yet.

So, which fanfics do you have to recommend? I'm always open for new reading material. (Provided it's worksafe, of course.)

From the anime.

6 Responses to “Fanfic Recs”
  1. Yes, indeed. I like Twoflower's Slayers stuff. I've only read through to Part 5 of "Reflect", but I'm going to continue reading it this weekend.

  2. IKnight says:

    I'm one of those people who don't dislike fanfiction in general (in fact, ideologically/theoretically speaking I support it as a fun example of the reader playing with the text) but who don't read it either. Those Hellblazer crossovers sound vaguely interesting, though.

  3. Catty Nebulart says:

    Probably a litte late but I always like this CCS story:

    Not sure if it will be to your taste however.

    I'm sure you would like Undocumented Features, I recommend starting with the Symphony. I'm also sure that Sakura shows up somewhere in UF.

  4. DKellis says:

    @Catty: A Capella is indeed a great story. One of the first CCS stories I read.

    I used to follow Undocumented Features several years ago. I stopped after I got kicked-banned from the #eyrie channel for criticizing some aspects of it. (The kick-banner wasn't the primary authors, to be fair.) Also, I clash with Gryphon often enough on the City of Heroes boards (from my view, he seems to like flame-baiting far too much) to really feel comfortable with following his stories deeply now, on the EPU forums and everything.

  5. Rick says:

    Here's a Haruhi fan fiction about Yuki and Kyon:
    The Love Affair of Nagato Yuki.
    Genre: Drama / Romance.

    Description: Nagato starts having nightmares and asks Kyon for help. But things complicate when Haruhi is able to see one of Nagato's dreams: A nightmare about herself!

    WARNING: The story gets somewhat complicated as it involves time travel, government conspiracies, realtime communication between different timeplanes, stabilization of time loops, telepathy, and sealed realities.

    NOTE: This is a sequel to the 4th Haruhi novel: "The Disappearance of Suzumiya Haruhi".